Investigation into the differences among several outdoor thermal comfort indices against field survey in subtropics

Abstract

Comfortable and healthy outdoor microclimates are beneficial to sustainable urban development. Based on a comprehensive comparison of some currently frequently used thermal comfort indices, including PMV, WBGT, PET, SET*, and UTCI, the differences among these indices are significant in dealing with the fundamental energy balance model, descriptive equations, and application boundary conditions. In order to validate these indices, a subjective questionnaire survey with field measurements was carried out on a university campus in Guangzhou in southern China. Results revealed strong linear relationships between operative temperature and mean radiant temperature (Tmrt), WBGT, PET, SET*, UTCI, as well as PMV. However, the relationships between these thermal comfort indices and the mean thermal sensation vote (MTSV) are not clear for a hot outdoor environment, especially when the operative temperature was above 34 °C. The ranges of the heat stress category and PMV need to be modified for the evaluation of hot outdoor environments.